How To Combine Keto & Intermittent Fasting For Weight Loss, Metabolic Health & More
Intermittent fasting and the ketogenic diet are two popular eating strategies that can both be beneficial for weight loss, metabolic health, and more. You might be wondering if combining them will help you reap even more rewards or just be too much of a good thing.
We investigated the benefits of fasting and the keto diet, and here's what we learned about the benefits of pairing them and how to do so safely and effectively.
Overview of intermittent fasting
Intermittent fasting (IF) is an umbrella term that describes the many ways you can go with and without food. (We have covered the ins and outs of IF in previous articles, and we recommend you start here if you're new to the concept of intermittent fasting.)
Very briefly, IF is unlike other "diets" in that it's just a pattern of eating based on time rather than food choices, so there are many different ways to do an intermittent fast.
The most common form of IF is time-restricted eating (TRE), which will be the focus of this article. TRE limits daily food intake to a fixed window of each day, typically ~8 hours. The eating window usually aligns with daylight. This leaves a ~16-hour fasting window that happens when the sun is set.
While the evidence linking IF with real hard clinical outcomes is limited, it is definitely a tool that shouldn't be ignored. Fasting is also not some new concept or "fad." Fasting has a history dating back millenniums as a therapy used to cure disease and as a religious practice that benefits the mind and body. Our biology is well equipped to go long periods without food. If it wasn't, we wouldn't be here today!
Benefits of IF:
- Weight loss
- Reduced caloric intake
- Metabolic health
- Autophagy and cellular cleanup
- Improved blood sugar levels
Overview of the keto diet
Speaking of the history of fasting…this is exactly what led to the introduction of what's known today as the ketogenic diet.
Keto is a way of eating that restricts carbohydrates to the point that our body needs to vet out an alternative fuel source to feed our glucose-hungry brain. (Unlike most of our tissues, the brain cannot burn fats for fuel.) That's where ketones come in.
When we lower carbohydrate intake, and by virtue, blood sugar and insulin levels, to the point that puts the brain at risk of an energy deficit, the liver starts converting fats (either from our diet or body fat stores if in a caloric deficit) into ketones.
This is what defines a keto diet: an elevation of ketones. It turns out that the brain loves ketones so much that it uses them even in the face of impaired energy metabolism. Ketones do a lot of other extraordinary things in the body that scientists are still unpacking.
It also shows promise for promoting brain health and treating mental health conditions10. "A ketogenic diet is a really important tool for people who are trying to improve their brain's access to energy and the overall health of their brain's metabolism," nutritional psychiatrist Georgia Ede, M.D., says on the mindbodygreen podcast.
Benefits of keto:
- Muscle preservation
- Appetite control
- Weight loss
- Blood sugar balance
- Potential brain health benefits and protection from neurodegenerative disaeses
Why combine them?
We can think of fasting and keto as two peas in a pod. We derive energy during fasting and following a keto diet in the same way: from fats and ketones.
Remember, the ketogenic diet was introduced as a dietary means of mimicking fasting. Because of this, they pair up nicely and often, are practiced in concert. Keto takes care of food choice (what to eat), while IF takes care of food timing (when to eat). Here are some reasons to combine the two:
Keto can make the transition over to IF smoother.
If intermittent fasting is going to be paired with any sort of diet, keto is ideal given the energy density of keto foods lends itself to reduced meal frequency.
If you go cold turkey into a fast from a high-carbohydrate diet, you will most likely experience some symptoms of low energy, low blood sugar, and hunger as your body transitions into ketosis. It would be like stepping out of a sauna into the winter air.
Beginning a fast off of a keto diet, however, is more seamless. It's less of a shock to the system since your metabolism is already happily running on fats and ketones. It's more like coming out of a sauna into warm sunlight. So, if you are new to IF, a keto diet can help smooth the transition.
A ketogenic diet can also, in many cases, make intermittent fasting easier.
IF can help you stay in ketosis.
Conversely, fasting can be a great tool to support your ketogenic diet. It can both kick-start ketosis (the state where your body uses broken-down fat for energy instead of glucose from carbs) and help you stay in ketosis for longer periods of time.
This is because fasting is the most cut-and-dried way to stimulate your body's own ketone production11 since it removes all glucose sources by removing all food. If you are following a ketogenic diet, intermittent fasting is a great tool for emptying your body's glucose stores, the way a keto diet does as well.
Keto and IF naturally work together.
The foods you eat on a keto diet tend to be more energy dense, and therefore you may need to eat less frequently on this plan. Unless you are trying to force multiple meals into your IF schedule, you typically end up removing snacks and/or a meal from your usual eating patterns while intermittent fasting too.
So, if you are eating a ketogenic diet and find you only really need two meals a day (maybe you aren't hungry throughout the morning, or you no longer desire that snack after dinner), well, now you're well on your way to time-restricted eating.
In addition, if you find a keto diet helps you intermittently fast with ease, this frees up hours of your day that might otherwise be spent thinking about, preparing, and eating food. This is an overlooked benefit of intermittent fasting that extends beyond metabolism and body weight and really could in some cases improve quality of life.
What to know about weight loss.
Keto and fasting are not magic weight loss solutions. However, they certainly can support an overall energy deficit when properly combined.
Whether or not the pair supports weight loss will come down to the individual since adherence to any diet is the best predictor of weight loss. In other words, if you can stick to a keto diet while intermittent fasting, then you will likely find success! However, if your intermittent fasting schedule leads you to binge on a tub of keto ice cream at the end of the day, then this strategy is not for you.
As of now, no research trials have studied using a ketogenic diet alongside time-restricted feeding for weight loss. However, given the promise of both interventions, it is likely that those studies will eventually be done,
Someone that doesn't want to lose weight? Combining keto and IF might still lead to a caloric deficit in your case, and spur weight loss that you weren't necessarily going for.
Tips for combining them:
Pair IF with a whole-foods ketogenic diet.
Real food should always be what makes up the vast majority of the diet. Opting for whole foods will also reduce the time you need to spend figuring out whether some ingredient listed on your packaged food that you can't even pronounce is "keto."
Lightweight and up the protein.
When paired with resistance training, adequate protein intake will be important for maintaining or building muscle15 in the face of long durations (e.g., 16 hours) without food. Protein will also help with appetite management if you find yourself unable to stick to your IF schedule because you're absolutely ravenous. Protein helps us stay full for longer, so use this to your advantage!
Both fasting and keto can lead to electrolyte imbalances by suppressing the hormone insulin16. Since insulin helps with sodium reabsorption, we can end up secreting sodium and with it potassium. So either liberally salt your food, or find a sugar-free electrolyte supplement to prevent any unwanted side effects of electrolyte imbalances (headaches, fatigue, cramps, etc.) when combining keto and IF.
Find your ideal eating window and keep it consistent.
First and foremost, eat when the sun is out. This is a foolproof way to stick to time-restricted eating, as it was designed by its originator, Satchidananda Panda, Ph.D.
His research protocol suggests avoiding eating at least two to three hours before your regular bedtime, eating after the sun has risen, and eating within a 12-hour window.
Within this framework, you can adjust your exact eating window based on your schedule, lifestyle, and preference. Maybe you skip breakfast and eat from noon to 8 p.m. or skip dinner and eat from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., for example. Here is more information about getting started on a 16-hour or 18-hour fast.
There is research to suggest if you are trying to optimize for metabolic health and glycemic control, then eating earlier in the day (i.e., early TRE) is best.
You just want to make sure the window isn't so short that you can't comfortably eat the calories and nutrition you need to support your activity, ideal body weight, and nutritional needs. It also should not be too long that it doesn't do much to help you achieve your goals.
Don't worry too much about exercise timing.
If your goals are to maximize muscle gains, for example, you'll want to position your eating window to begin when you complete your workout. You could also train within your eating window. When compared to eating over the course of the day, resistance training paired with TRE18 (when training takes place in the eating window) leads to similar gains in muscle. Though, there is also a study19 that found training in the fasted state may increase our muscle's response to protein intake post-exercise.
So, it is likely that you can train the way you prefer (fed versus fasted) without worry. To optimize recovery, choose an eating window in close proximity to your gym session and ensure adequate protein intake post-workout.
Sample meal plan and schedule.
How many meals per day you eat on keto and IF will come down to your meal sizes, food preferences, and schedule but will likely be one to three meals. This is an example using an 8-hour eating window, but it can be condensed to eliminate one of the meals. In this case, add more proteins and fats (or just fatty proteins like oily fish and eggs) to the meals you are eating.
Sip water, coffee, tea, or noncaloric beverage of choice.
Pro tip on coffee:
Breakfast (11 a.m.):
Option 1: Eggs cooked how you like with a side of avocado and sauteed spinach.
Option 2: Chia pudding with full-fat coconut cream, protein powder, and chopped nuts.
Lunch (3 p.m.):
Option 1: Salmon (or sardines) salad with chopped veg, cheese, avocado, seeds, and an olive-oil-based dressing. Add a boiled egg or two for some extra protein.
Option 2: Smoothie with high-fat dairy or nut milk as base, protein powder, greens, nut butter, and a handful of berries (optional). If you've never subbed frozen fruit for steamed then frozen cauliflower, give it a go! It thickens up your smoothies as a frozen banana would.
Dinner (6 p.m.):
Option 1: Grilled fish or steak (in moderation) with steamed nonstarchy vegetable with olive oil or butter.
Option 2: Taco bowls with mince (chicken, beef, turkey, etc.) seasoned with taco spices and cooked with lots of onions and garlic, served over cauliflower rice, with avocado, salsa, shredded cheese, chopped jalapeños, and cilantro. Top with tahini mixed with lime juice.
Dessert (before 7 p.m.):
Option 1: Heavy whipping cream (whipped) with a few berries.
Option 2: A square of 90-100% dark chocolate.
Side effects and who shouldn't combine keto with IF.
If you are getting adequate nutrition and calories during your eating window, then there really is no risk to the simple advice to eat when the sun is up (< 12 hours).
Keto and TRE, both separate and paired, are not recommended for pregnant and breastfeeding women, and you should seek professional advice from your doctor if you are interested in either from a health perspective depending on your current health status.
Those who may be vulnerable to unwanted weight loss or calorie restriction such as young, lean, and/or very active individuals as well as menstruating women are at higher risk for side effects, if pairing the two makes it difficult to consume enough calories and nutrition.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many hours should you intermittently fast on keto?
The most common schedule for intermittent fasting is eating within an 8-hour window and fasting for 16 hours. Learn more about which schedule is right for you here.
Will a 16-hour fast put me in ketosis?
This can be different for everyone. While someone may go into ketosis after a 12-hour fast, it may take another person 24 hours. To find out what works for you personally, an at-home ketone test can be a good starting point.
How much weight will I lose on keto and intermittent fasting?
This depends on many variables. However, a gradual, sustainable rate of weight loss is 1 to 2 pounds per week.
Intermittent fasting and the keto diet pair well together given their overlap in promoting the use of fats and ketones for fuel. You can use a keto diet to make the transitions from fed to fasted a bit smoother, complementing your fasting schedule, and vice versa. You might even naturally end up intermittent fasting while on keto if the diet ends up steadying your appetite. Just follow the tips outlined in this article to make sure you're getting the most out of this natural combination.
Kristi Storoschuk is a PhD student in the Muscle Physiology Lab at Queen's University in Ontario, Canada where she is studying the effects of fasted exercise on metabolic flexibility and blood sugar control. Outside her research Kristi works in science communication with a focus on ketogenic diets, exercise, and metabolic health. When she's not writing and researching, you'll find her in her gym doing CrossFit, traveling the world, or in the kitchen cooking healthy eats.