Uh, Is Air-Drying Your Hair More Damaging Than Heat? We Got The Scoop
Heat harms your hair—we'll assume you're well aware of this hard truth. While you can take proactive measures to prevent breakage (i.e., a thermal protectant and low-heat setting), taking a hot tool to the strands ultimately restructures your hair pattern to get the results you want, which does a number on those bonds over time. Now, we're not going to shame anyone for occasionally plugging in the blow dryer, but we often say an air-dry is the best dry, if you can swing it.
So imagine our shock when we came across a string of videos on TikTok claiming an air-dry is more damaging than heat—with some research to back it up, too. If you just reconsidered your wash day, you're not alone. Below, we asked the experts to weigh in.
Air-drying can damage hair: True or false?
Most of the frenzy comes from this 2011 study from the journal Annals of Dermatology, which tested a bunch of different blow-dryer settings (lengths and distances), versus an air-dry at room temperature. The results? "Although using a hair dryer causes more surface damage than natural drying, using a hair dryer at a distance of 15 centimeters with continuous motion causes less damage than drying hair naturally." The researchers explain that air-drying actually compromised the cell membrane complex (CMC) in the cortex of the hair, rather than the surface (or cuticle), which ultimately created more inner structural damage than heat.
If all this science jargon leaves you scratching your head, here's a little hair anatomy for your day: Each strand is made up of three layers—the inner fiber called the medulla, the middle layer called the cortex, and an outer layer called the cuticle. Right on the outside of that middle cortex layer, you have the CMC. "The cell membrane complex is the material that glues hair cells together and is where hair hydration 'lives,'" explains hairstylist Miko Branch, co-founder of natural hair care brand Miss Jessie's. "When the CMC layer is exposed, you lose essential hydration, which can cause damage to the hair shaft."
Your hair is also structurally at its weakest when it's wet, as the strands swell up with water—so if your hair stays wet for a long period of time, the CMC "glue" holding the hair cells together can start to expand, and that's when you can run into a concern called hygral fatigue (or damage from excessive moisture). From there, you might experience brittle strands, tangling, frizz, breakage, and low elasticity, says Branch.
However! That's all assuming your hair stays wet and fragile for a long, long time. "I don't think 'air-drying' is the problem. I think air-drying for an extended period of time is problematic," says celebrity curl expert Nai'vasha, founder of Curl Queen. "The weight of wet strands for an excessive time plus the hygral fatigue is where the breakage starts, in my opinion, versus air-drying in its entirety." So let's all take a breath and let go of the notion that air-drying itself is more damaging than heat. Wet strands are extremely vulnerable, yes, but if your hair naturally dries rather quickly, you should have little to worry about.
In fact, that brings me to an important point: It looks like this study didn't take participants' hair texture and porosity into account, which totally could have influenced the results. For instance, low porosity hair takes longer to dry after getting wet, as the denser cuticles are holding all that water in. So someone with low porosity hair might have experienced more structural damage from the air-dry, as the CMC tends to swell up for longer.
High porosity hair, on the other hand, means the cuticles are more open, so water evaporates easily. Of course, it also means that water soaks in easier, which could also lead to hygral fatigue. As Branch notes, "Curly or kinky textures with high porosity can absorb much higher amounts of water, leading to fragility, breakage and increased damage to the CMC." Hair has many, many variables and nuances, and figuring out what works for your own tresses is a lifelong, ever-evolving journey.
How to quickly air-dry your hair.
If you are worried about your air-dry extending hours (thus leaving your strands vulnerable to breakage) there are some ways you can speed up the process, without turning on the blow-dryer, and protect those strands as they dry:
- Cold blast: "To minimize damaging effects of air drying, finish your shower with a cold rinse to close the hair cuticle and seal in the moisture from your conditioner," says Branch. You can read all about the benefits of cold showers here, but cold water flattens the hair cuticles—and when your cuticles are flat, your hair is healthier, shinier, and smoother.
- Dry with a gentle towel or T-shirt: To quickly wick away water from the strands, both Branch and Nai'vasha recommend grabbing a soft microfiber towel (or, better yet, a cotton T-shirt) to absorb excess moisture. Just don't tousle your strands too aggressively, or you might cause some physical wear and tear.
- Use a leave-in or oil: We're unsure if the participants in the study used leave-in treatments before air-drying, but these are great for strengthening the hair and protecting against breakage. Most formulas come loaded with hair-healthy nutrients to seal in moisture, add shine, and fight damage. For an oil option, we recommend Miss Jessie's Grow Strong Mafura Hair Oil, or you can find our favorite leave-in conditioners here.
- Use a diffuser: OK, technically this isn't an air-dry tip, but if you are going to use a hot tool (especially those with curls, kinks, and coils), a diffuser is your least damaging option. It literally diffuses the airflow: "The attachment has dozens of tiny holes for the air to escape, so it's not as direct, like that of a nozzle," celebrity hairstylist Marcus Francis, brand ambassador for BetterNatured once shared with mbg. "The restricted hair from the dryer allows it to focus more on letting the heat come out." It's basically a sped-up version of air-drying.
Is air-drying more damaging than heat? Generally, I'd still say no, but there are some potential downsides to leaving your hair wet for a long period of time. Point being: It's the length of the air-dry that can be problematic, not the air-dry itself, and there are ways to speed up the process to make it less of an issue. For now, we say do what's best for your own head of hair: If that means plugging in the blow dryer every so often, so be it (still, use a heat protectant and low setting); if that means honing the art of the air-dry, go right ahead. Listen to what your own strands are telling you, and don't let the TikToks get you down.
Jamie Schneider is the Associate Beauty & Wellness Editor at mindbodygreen. She has a B.A. in Organizational Studies and English from the University of Michigan, and her work has appeared in Coveteur, The Chill Times, and Wyld Skincare. In her role at mbg, she reports on everything from the top beauty industry trends, to the gut-skin connection and the microbiome, to the latest expert makeup hacks. She currently lives in New York City.