Skip to content

The Benefits Of A Hybrid Mattress + A Shopping Guide

Emma Loewe
Author:
Updated on January 15, 2023
Emma Loewe
mbg Sustainability + Health Director
By Emma Loewe
mbg Sustainability + Health Director
Emma Loewe is the Senior Sustainability Editor at mindbodygreen and the author of "Return to Nature: The New Science of How Natural Landscapes Restore Us."
Last updated on January 15, 2023
Our editors have independently chosen the products listed on this page. If you purchase something mentioned in this article, we may earn a small commission.

Oftentimes, you need to kiss a few frogs before finding your dream mattress. While cushy foam options may feel too soft for your liking, spring beds can be too firm. Hybrid mattresses—which combine the functionalities of both—tend to be ideal for the widest variety of sleepers. No matter what your preferred sleeping position is, there's likely a hybrid mattress that's right for you.

Today, we're sharing everything you need to know about this mattress type, how to choose the best hybrid mattress for you, and six brands that could be your prince or princess charming.

What is a hybrid mattress?

Hybrid mattresses are composed of a layer of firm spring coils covered with a softer layer like memory foam or natural latex. They combine the firm qualities of a spring mattress with the soft, absorbent qualities of foam into a hybrid that many sleepers find comfortable. Hybrid mattresses can be comfortable for side sleepers, back sleepers, and stomach sleepers, depending on their firmness.

Ideally, your hybrid mattress will hug your body but also leave you free to move around and change sleeping positions as the night goes on. And sleep experts agree that it's worth taking your time to find this perfect fit. "The average person will spend one-third of their life on a mattress, so choosing one that is comfortable and supportive to health is important," Alan Hedge, Ph.D., an ergonomics researcher and professor emeritus at Cornell University, tells mbg.

"If we don't have a comfortable mattress providing us adequate support, we won't get good-quality sleep, which has a cascade of effects," adds Doug Cary, Ph.D., a physiotherapist and sleep posture researcher based in Australia. "There is no system in the human body that is not affected by lack of sleep."

Benefits of a hybrid mattress.

  • Supportive for back, side, and stomach sleepers
  • Promotes healthy sleep posture
  • Minimizes stiffness or pain upon waking
  • Comfortable
  • Easy to move around in
  • Breathable
  • Quiet motion transfer
  • Can be affordable

What to look for in a hybrid mattress.

Not all mattresses are created equal, and Cary and Hedge both agree that you'll want to try out a mattress for yourself before buying. That's the only way to truly ensure that it's comfortable for you and your body type. When searching for your perfect mattress, these are the boxes they say to tick:

1.

It's the right firmness level.

Hedge explains that you'll want to avoid mattresses that feel too soft or too hard to you.

"If a mattress is too soft, it can feel comfortable in the short term, but it will restrict movement during the night, which can restrict circulation to muscles, and it will be uncomfortable in the long term (like sitting on a bean bag chair)," he explains. If a mattress is too hard, on the other hand, "it will compress the soft tissues of the body (like sitting on a rock-hard chair)."

The right hybrid mattress will strike a nice balance between these two: feeling comfortable yet supportive. Any new mattress can be an adjustment at first, so give it a few nights before gauging how the firmness feels to you.

2.

It allows for movement.

Hedge and Cary explain that it's perfectly normal to move around in your sleep—and your mattress should give you the freedom to do so.

"Keeping the body still in one position restricts blood circulation, which disturbs muscle function, causing stiffness and pain," Hedge explains. "Movement is important for spreading skin pressure over different body regions and promoting good circulation."

A hybrid mattress' spring layer should allow for easy movement, while its plush layer should minimize any bed squeaking as you adjust position.

3.

It promotes good sleep posture.

Healthy sleep posture allows you to stay in a neutral, comfortable position as you rest. It shouldn't lead to hyperextension or put too much pressure on any one part of the body. After years of studying people's sleep habits, Cary has found that back sleeping and side sleeping tend to be the most supportive sleep postures—but there's a catch. Side sleepers will want to make sure that their legs are aligned as they sleep. If one knee is farther forward than the other, it can lead to a rotation in the spine, causing you to wake up with pain or stiffness in the neck or back.

He's found that it's possible to train yourself to have better sleep posture (and offers a free program to help), but it will be more difficult if you're sleeping on the wrong mattress.

Medium-firm mattresses tend to be best for promoting healthy sleep positioning, and many hybrid mattresses fit into this category.

4.

It's breathable.

Finally, Hedge adds that you'll want to find a mattress that doesn't trap heat during the night, as toasty environments can disrupt sleep quality (especially for those who are already prone to running hot while they sleep). You'll likely need to spend the whole night on a mattress to get a sense of this; yet another reason to try before you buy.

How we picked:

Trial Period

Each of these mattresses has a trial period of at least 100 nights, so you can easily try them out to make sure they check the above boxes for you. 

Materials

We prefer products to be made using natural, nontoxic materials whenever possible. We prioritized mattresses made using natural foams and marked when they are not.

Firmness

We opted for medium and medium-firm models, since these tend to be the most supportive for various sleep postures.

Reviews

A wide range of feedback is important, so we made sure to read reviews for every mattress we chose, and narrowed it down based on the good and the bad.

Our picks for the best hybrid mattresses of 2023

Best for back pain: The WinkBed

Pros:

  • Designed for people with back pain
  • Multiple firmness options

Cons:

  • Synthetic foam
Materials: CertiPUR-US® certified foamsPocketed coils
Sizes available: TwinTwin XLFullQueenKingCalifornia King
Trial period: 120 nights
Warranty: Lifetime

For back pain sufferers, WinkBed's mattress comes with a "lumbar" layer in the middle for added support for your spine. It's been named the best bed for back pain sufferers by many third-party sites including Wirecutter and the Sleep Foundation.

The hybrid also comes in four firmness levels (soft, firm, extra firm, and plus for heavier sleepers) and has a lifetime warranty. It's made from conventional poly foam, though; for a small sustainable perk, its spring coils are made from recycled material.

Best fast delivery: Leesa Hybrid Mattress

Pros:

  • Free & fast shipping
  • Cooling

Cons:

  • Synthetic foam
Materials: Pocket SpringsCertiPUR-US® certified foamsMemory foam
Sizes available: TwinTwin XLFullQueenKingCalifornia King
Trial period: 120 nights
Warranty: Lifetime

If you want to try out a new mattress stat, Leesa can do that for you. Your order will go out to you within three to five businesses days and arrive in a box for you to unpack yourself. Reviewers rave about the hybrid design that supports the neck and hips, and many of them say that this mattress has helped ease arthritis pain as well as the general aches of getting older. The finishing touch is a top layer that is hole-punched to stay cool all night. Leesa is also a B Corp certified brand, making them a leader in the sustainable mattress space.

Advertisement
This ad is displayed using third party content and we do not control its accessibility features.

Best for side sleepers: Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress

Pros:

  • Designed for ergonomic alignment
  • Great for side sleepers

Cons:

  • Synthetic foam
Materials: CertiPUR-US® certified foamsSprings
Sizes available: Twin XLFullQueenKingCalifornia King
Trial period: 100 nights
Warranty: 10-year

The ergonomic zones of this mattress are great for side sleepers (most of us, it turns out!). As Cary pointed out, those who sleep on their side will want to be mindful of their sleep posture because this position can easily strain the back and hips. Casper's Nova Hybrid zones (soft under the head and feet and firmer under the shoulders, hips, waist, and lower back for a more comfortable fit) can help keep you in good sleep form.

This mattress has a cushy feel, well suited for side sleepers seeking a softer bed. It's made of a combination of polyurethane foam and memory foam (we'd prefer to see natural latex, but Casper at least tests its foam for emissions).

Best overall: Birch Natural Mattress

Pros:

  • Made from organic materials (latex, cotton, and wool)
  • Optional topper for added comfort

Cons:

  • Expensive
Materials: GOLS certified organic latexGOTS certified organic cottonGOTS certified organic woolPocketed coils
Sizes available: TwinTwin XLFullQueenKingCalifornia King
Trial period: 100 nights
Warranty: 25-year

Helix is a standout in the bed-in-a-box space for its wide range of personalized, comfortable mattress options. Their Natural Mattress from child company Birch combines functionality with sustainability. Made of organic wool and cotton and natural latex, it's a cozy bed that you can feel great sleeping on. It falls squarely in the medium-firm range. Those seeking more softness can add the accompanying topper (also organic) but it will set you back $450.

Advertisement
This ad is displayed using third party content and we do not control its accessibility features.

Best organic: Plush Beds The Botanical Bliss® Organic Latex Mattress

Pros:

  • Made from organic materials (latex, cotton, and wool)
  • Expert-recommended

Cons:

  • Expensive
Materials: GOLS certified organic latexGOTS certified organic cottonGOTS certified organic woolPocketed coils
Sizes available: TwinTwin XLFullQueenKingCalifornia KingSplit KingSplit California King
Trial period: 100 nights
Warranty: Lifetime

While some beds are treated with lots of potential irritants, Plush Beds are certified free of flame retardants, heavy metals, lead, and a whole host of other nasties. Their latex, wool, and cotton layers are also certified organic. If you're concerned about the VOCs emitted by mattresses over time (we wouldn't blame you), this is a solid pick. Reviewers also note that it's supremely comfortable, and both the firm and medium-firm options get high marks for helping all sorts of sleepers snooze through the night comfortably.

Best for couples: Nest Sparrow Signature Hybrid Memory Foam

Pros:

  • Option to split firmness (with King and Cal King)
  • Customizable comfort layer

Cons:

  • Synthetic foam
  • Expensive
Materials: CertiPUR-US® certified foamsGel-infused memory foam
Sizes available: TwinTwin XLFullQueenKingCalifornia KingSplit KingSplit California King
Trial period: 365 nights
Warranty: Lifetime

The most versatile mattress on the list, Nest lets you easily add and remove foam layers if you're looking for a softer or firmer feel. And if you share the bed with someone who prefers a totally different firmness, you have the option to split levels with the King and Cal King (both $1,799) sizes. You'll both appreciate Nest's lifetime warranty and 365-night trial period. This is another bed-in-the-box model, and swapping out the foam layers does take some maneuvering, so it's not necessarily a set-it-and-forget-it sleep experience. This bed also uses memory foam, not natural latex.

Advertisement
This ad is displayed using third party content and we do not control its accessibility features.

FAQ

Who are hybrid beds good for?

Depending on their firmness, hybrid mattresses can be good for any type of sleeper. That said, you will want to take into account the same considerations you would with any mattress: sleeping position, materials, quality, firmness, and budget.

What is the best hybrid mattress to purchase?

The best hybrid mattress for you is the one that matches your needs and preferences most closely. Consider the criteria we've mentioned, and determine which of these options best fits your needs.

What are the negatives of a hybrid mattress?

Many hybrid mattresses are made with memory foam, which is not the most sustainable choice. Memory foams are more likely to off-gas volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that may cause respiratory irritation and skin irritation, than 100% natural latex foam. Plus, traditional foams are petroleum-based, so they're not doing our planet any favors.

The takeaway.

Hybrid mattresses can set you up for a happy-medium sleep experience. They're not too soft, not too firm, and provide the best of both spring mattresses and foam ones to help you fall asleep fast and stay snoozing comfortably through the night. If you're still in the market for more recommendations, here are our favorite nontoxic mattresses and mattresses for side sleepers.

Meet The Experts

Emma Loewe is the Senior Sustainability Editor at mindbodygreen and the author of "Return to Nature: The New Science of How Natural Landscapes Restore Us."