Advertisement
A Nutritional Psychiatrist's (Very) Hot Take On 3 Buzzy Brain Foods
Georgia Ede, M.D., doesn't believe in brain foods. Now, this may sound shocking coming from a Harvard-trained nutritional psychiatrist, especially one who just released a book called Change Your Diet, Change Your Mind, but it's not the foods themselves she's against—it's the idea that one or two superfoods can transform your brain that Ede wants to dismantle.
"The things that you can do to improve your brain health have very little to do with adding special things to the diet," she shares on this episode of the mindbodygreen podcast. "They really have to do with subtracting things from the diet that are working against your brain in the first place." You know, ultra-processed foods, inflammatory seed oils, and the like.
And on the topic of buzzy brain foods, Ede is full of hot takes—and she also has the science to back them up. Below, find her expert POV:
Red wine
Red wine is often touted as the healthiest alcoholic beverage you can have, due to its polyphenols and antioxidants1. However, "As a psychiatrist who focuses on optimizing brain health, I really can't recommend red wine as a part of a healthy diet," Ede declares.
That doesn't mean you can't ever drink a glass or two! If you do drink, then it's a fine option. But if you don't drink, don't add it to your diet in the hopes of consuming more polyphenols. The downsides of alcohol far outweigh the antioxidant benefits it may have.
"What I don't want people to think is that red wine is a brain-healthy beverage," she adds. "Alcohol is a powerful promoter of oxidative stress and inflammation2. It's also 100% guaranteed to disrupt your sleep quality." If you're struggling with mental health, she even recommends abstaining from alcohol for 30 days (great timing—it's Dry January!)
If you don't notice a difference, "you can make that informed choice [of] where you stand in terms of your ability to safely consume moderate amounts of red wine," she explains. But she wants to dismantle the notion that the antioxidants in red wine will serve your brain in a meaningful way. "We can't put it in the same category as something that may have potential benefits or even be completely benign because it does have risks," she adds.
Meat (or lack thereof)
Meat—specifically red meat—has long been vilified when it comes to brain health. One study has even associated red and processed meat consumption with an increased risk for Alzheimer's (and there's way more anti-meat research where that came from).
But if you take a closer look at the science, says Ede, it's not the meat itself that's bad for us—it's likely the processing. High-quality meat is actually very nutrient dense, and all meat is considered a complete source of protein as it contains all nine essential amino acids your body needs—many of which are crucial for cognition.
"This is a natural, whole food that we've been eating since time immemorial," Ede shares. Of course, you should do what's best for your own body—perhaps some basic blood work to figure out how much meat you can tolerate—but Eden doesn't subscribe to the pervasive argument that meat is "bad" for us.
"If you're looking for optimal brain health, you do need to include some animal foods in the diet," she adds. Not just red meat but wild-caught fatty fish, chicken, eggs, and other lean proteins.
Nuts, seeds, and legumes
Nuts, seeds, and legumes are beloved brain foods. Research has found that the nutrients in almonds, hazelnuts, and walnuts could help prevent or even manage Alzheimer's disease3. Ask a brain health expert what's on their grocery list, and chances are some sort of nut or seed makes the cut—but Ede begs to differ.
"Just because a food contains a nutrient doesn't necessarily mean we can access it," she explains. You see, some plant foods contain anti-nutrients meant to protect the baby plant against aggressors. They essentially "guard" their nutrients, "so it can be much harder for us to access nutrients from plant foods," Ede adds.
Cooking, sprouting, and fermenting these foods can offset those anti-nutrients, but if you're eating them raw and mixed with other nutrient-rich animal foods, you might not get the most nutritional bang for your buck.
She references an old study that examined this very scenario: "If you eat oysters by themselves, you will see a very nice rise in blood zinc levels, signifying that you have absorbed a lot of the zinc from those oysters," she notes. "If you eat that same amount of oysters with black beans, you absorb about half of the zinc from those oysters. And if you eat the same amount of oysters with corn tortillas, you absorb virtually none of the zinc from those oysters. It's a very powerful effect."
Let us be clear: This doesn't mean you should forgo legumes, nuts, and seeds. They are certainly part of a brain-healthy diet. But if your main goal is to reap vitamins and minerals from animal sources, you might not want to pair those foods with plants known for their anti-nutrient content. Better to have those beans, nuts, or seeds as a snack at a different time of the day.
The takeaway
Brain foods (berries, avocados, dark chocolate, etc.) are wonderful to incorporate into your diet—please, keep eating them! Just don't think those items alone will completely transform your brain health. And if your diet is full of processed, inflammatory foods, a cup of antioxidant-rich berries won't pull much weight. According to Ede, it's better to start by ridding the inflammatory, oxidative stress-promoting foods in your diet; then you can start to focus on brain-supporting superstars. And if you struggle with mental health specifically, you may just want to keep her above caveats in mind.
We hope you enjoy this episode! And don't forget to subscribe to our podcast on iTunes, Google Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or YouTube!
Watch Next
Enjoy some of our favorite clips from classes
Enjoy some of our favorite clips from classes
What Is Meditation?
Mindfulness/Spirituality | Light Watkins
Box Breathing
Mindfulness/Spirituality | Gwen Dittmar
What Breathwork Can Address
Mindfulness/Spirituality | Gwen Dittmar
The 8 Limbs of Yoga - What is Asana?
Yoga | Caley Alyssa
Two Standing Postures to Open Up Tight Hips
Yoga | Caley Alyssa
How Plants Can Optimize Athletic Performance
Nutrition | Rich Roll
What to Eat Before a Workout
Nutrition | Rich Roll
How Ayurveda Helps Us Navigate Modern Life
Nutrition | Sahara Rose
Messages About Love & Relationships
Love & Relationships | Esther Perel
Love Languages
Love & Relationships | Esther Perel
What Is Meditation?
Box Breathing
What Breathwork Can Address
The 8 Limbs of Yoga - What is Asana?
Two Standing Postures to Open Up Tight Hips
How Plants Can Optimize Athletic Performance
What to Eat Before a Workout
How Ayurveda Helps Us Navigate Modern Life
Messages About Love & Relationships
Love Languages
Advertisement
The Sleep Routine That Helps Me Spend Up To 25% Of The Night In REM Sleep
Jill Carnahan, MD ABIHM, ABoIM, IFMCP
The Sleep Routine That Helps Me Spend Up To 25% Of The Night In REM Sleep
Jill Carnahan, MD ABIHM, ABoIM, IFMCP
The Sleep Routine That Helps Me Spend Up To 25% Of The Night In REM Sleep
Jill Carnahan, MD ABIHM, ABoIM, IFMCP
The Sleep Routine That Helps Me Spend Up To 25% Of The Night In REM Sleep
Jill Carnahan, MD ABIHM, ABoIM, IFMCP