DIY: Slow-Cooker Probiotic Greek Yogurt

When it comes to choosing a healthy yogurt the supermarket can be a minefield. Most “healthy” yogurts (in fact, most “healthy” dairy products) are chock full of sugar. Especially bad are the ones with a low-fat stamp splashed across the packet. When fat is removed from a product, sugar is added to make up for loss of flavor.

So how to get around it? Make your own yogurt, of course!

Here's a super simple recipe to get you started!

Slow-Cooker Probiotic Greek Yogurt

Makes about 4 cups of yogurt


  • 8½ cups full-fat milk (preferably organic)
  • ½ cup full-fat organic, natural yogurt with live cultures, at room temperature

Special equipment

  • A slow cooker


Pour the milk into your slow cooker insert. Cover and cook on low for 2 1/2 hours. Allow mixture to sit for another 3 hours with the lid on.

Add yogurt to the milk and gently stir through, replace the lid. Wrap a bath towel around slow cooker and the lid. (Blocking out any light and keeping the cooker warm.) Leave the yogurt mixture in the slow cooker for 8-12 hours.

After 12 hours you will have slightly runny yogurt. Leave for a few hours longer if you want a thicker yogurt. For Greek-style yogurt, line a strainer with cheesecloth or with muslin. Place the strainer over a bowl (to catch excess whey) pour mixture into strainer and strain for at least one hour. The longer you strain, the thicker the yogurt will be.

Store in the fridge once desired consistency is achieved.

Tip: freeze the excess whey in ice cube trays and use for your next batch of yogurt. Simply remove from the freezer and allow to return to room temperature before adding to yogurt. Alternatively, add the whey to smoothies for a nice dose of probiotics.

Serving suggestions: sprinkle your yogurt with granola, cinnamon, brown rice syrup, cacao nibs or coconut flakes.

This recipe is from the new I Quit Sugar Slow Cooker Cookbook.

You May Also Enjoy

7 Tips To Make A Smoothie That Doesn't Have A Ton Of Sugar

Smoothies are a great way to pack in tons nutrients into one delicious drink. The bad news is, all the fruit can add up to a lot of sugar. An apple and banana combined have 30 grams of sugar — almost  Read

About the Author

Sarah Wilson is a NYT best-selling author, tv host, blogger and wellness coach whose journalism career has spanned 20 years across television, radio, magazines, newspapers and online. She’s the former editor of Cosmopolitan magazine and was the host of MasterChef Australia, the highest rating show in Australian TV history.

Sarah is an adept social commentator, following a career that’s spanned politics, health advocacy, restaurant reviewing, and opinion writing. She’s also a qualified Health Coach with the Institute for Integrative Nutrition in New York.

Sarah is the author of the best-seller I Quit Sugar, and recent Australian release I Quit Sugar For Life. She's also authored best-selling ebooks available at Check out the latest release I Quit Sugar Slow Cooker Cookbook. Her 8-Week Program has seen over 495 000 people quit sugar. Register today for the next 8-Week Program launching in late September.