Want To Stop Your Antidepressant? Here's How
Kelly Brogan, M.D., is a Manhattan-based holistic women’s health psychiatrist, author of the book, A Mind of Your Own and co-editor of the landmark textbook, Integrative Therapies for Depression. She is board certified in psychiatry, psychosomatic medicine, and integrative holistic medicine, and is specialized in a root-cause resolution approach to psychiatric syndromes and symptoms.
Note: The author acknowledges, with great compassion, that this is a challenging topic for the many individuals who make the difficult decision to begin treatment with psychiatric medication. All patients must be given the most complete and accurate information about these medications, including side effects (risk for dependence, violence, impulsivity, etc), the importance of properly tapering off medication, the institutional incentives for medical doctors, educators, and others to advocate for their use, and the availability of effective non-pharmaceutical avenues of treatment that can address root causes of mental illness and behavioral problems. What follows herein is a discussion of steps that the author believes should be taken in anticipation of any medication taper, and the subsequent taper should be handled by an experienced professional. Despite these considerations, some patients may be unable to taper which, in the author's opinion, speaks to the important of true informed consent prior to medication initiation. This blog is not medical advice and does not replace consultation with a qualified medical professional of your choosing.
If you squeeze a spring and you hold it there, steadily for a couple of hours, and then you suddenly let go, what happens? It bursts into expansion, maybe double its natural size and reverberates for a while until it comes to a resting place. This is the example that I use when I describe the effects that antidepressants have on brain chemistry.
Despite being taught, in my training, that antidepressants were to the depressed (and to the anxious, OCD, IBS, PTSD, bulemic, anorexic, etc.) what glasses are to the near-sighted, I don’t buy this anymore. I don’t think patients are getting the whole truth.
Here’s the deal: There is not a single human study that supports the “monoamine hypothesis” of depression, which is the idea that depression is caused by a certain kind of chemical imbalance in the brain, such as under-activity of serotonin. The only studies in which tryptophan (an amino acid precursor to serotonin) depletion resulted in depression were in patients who had previously taken antidepressants.
Imaging studies, post-mortem suicide assessments, and animal models have never yielded consistent patterns of neurotransmitter levels, metabolites, or receptor profiles. Compelling discussions like this one by Moncrieff and Cohen suggest that antidepressants actually create abnormal states rather than repair them. They use the analogy of alcohol’s disinhibiting effects: just because booze can ease one's social phobia, does not imply that alcohol is an appropriate treatment nor a correcting agent.
Direct-to-consumer advertising in America has allowed pharmaceutical companies to “teach” the public about brain chemical imbalances and serotonin deficiencies through cleverly worded taglines and absent FDA-policing. The disconnect between available evidence and advertisements is explored in this excellent commentary.
But they do work! say many patients and their prescribers. And they do work! Thanks to active placebo effect or expectations of relief that manifest as actual physiologic changes as demonstrated by this metanalysis by Dr. Irving Kirsch, a placebo effect expert. He also collected unpublished data to show that more studies demonstrated lack of effect compared to marginal benefit largely attributed to placebo.
So what? Why come off antidepressants?
What are some of the undisclosed concerns about long-term treatment? They include chronic illness, risk of “relapse” increased by treatment as demonstrated by this study, increased disability, and even decreased benefit from exercise! Read more about the potential concerns here.
With some of these considerations in mind, you may be thinking, get me off this stuff! I’m done!
Not so fast.
What has fueled my fire about the irresponsible prescribing of psychiatric medications is bearing witness to cases of "severe discontinuation syndrome," as the field euphemistically refers to the months to years of nervous system instability that can result from medication taper. The process of coming off of antidepressants is just that, a process.
If you've been treated for longer than two months it must be (painstakingly) slow with small incremental decreases in medication doses and use of liquid preparations and compounds when small increments are not available.
My approach to supporting medication taper is to promote resilience before the taper so that your body is very able to adapt to the change. This is the idea of draining your bucket so that it doesn’t overflow when the “Where-are-my-meds?!” brain and body bomb drops.
Here are what I believe to be the most important preparatory steps:
1. Balance blood sugar, support natural fats, and calm inflammation
Blood sugar instability can drag your insulin and cortisol levels around to an extent that impacts your thyroid, sex hormones, and immunity. Low fat or diets that are heavy on the wrong fat diets (trans, hydrogenated, heated vegetable oils) can compromise your central nervous system’s ability to support cell membrane functioning as well as hormone production. Inflammatory foods like gluten can also provoke brain-based reactions and immune system dysregulation. For these reasons and more, I recommend a no-grain Paleo diet that eliminates corn, soy, dairy, and gluten, at a minimum. It’s the most effective way to control for these variables.
2. Support your adrenals.
If you want to promote resiliency, train your body to respond with ease to stress. 20 minutes of relaxation response, i.e. guided meditation, breathing, or progressive muscle relaxation is an incredibly powerful tool. Start with three minutes!
3. Heal the gut.
Make sure you're pooping daily, have resolved gas, bloating, and indigestion through the use of anitmicrobials, gut healing agents like aloe and glutamine, and probiotics. The gut/brain axis is a major focus of resolving underlying inflammatory drivers of what likely got you on meds in the first place. Diet and stress minimization will go a long way toward resolving gut problems, but a stool analysis may also be indicated.
4. Seek methylation support.
B vitamins are critical for detox, cell function, and neurotransmitter creation. (So much so that methylfolate or activated B9 is marketed as an antidepressant called Deplin.) Personal optimization of these is best done with someone who knows about genetic variants discussed here.
5. Try other helpful tools.
I focus on calming the nervous system during medication tapers. Agents that have been identified as NMDA modulators or natural molecules that buffer the effects of excitatory glutamate are magnesium, zinc, N-acetylcysteine, and phenibut or GABA. I don’t always use amino acids as primary therapy, but they can be essential during a taper because of signals of “deficiency” that the body may be getting in the wake of medication discontinuation. Tryptophan and 5HTP, and L-tyrosine and dL-phenylalanine can be effective support. Inositol, a membrane stabilizer, and St. John’s Wort can also serve as transitional aids, which can relieve symptoms of anxiety or dips in mood.
Mostly, I counsel patients not to be afraid.
Psychiatrists are so driven by fear and a need to control and regulate the emotional experience. Once these first several steps are underway, there is a strong possibility that the original driver of your symptoms has been addressed. You may not have the same need or even be deriving much benefit from medication. In the end, I believe it is everyone’s choice to manage their health in a way that resonates with their beliefs about health and wellness.
This decision should be made with eyes wide open; however, and preferably with gentle interventions preceding more aggressive ones. The complexity of the body is awe-inspiring, and depression is a syndrome that has many many different causes. Look to the root, look to healing, and look to restoration for real lasting change.