Why BMI Is A Terrible Measure Of Your Health
You May Also Enjoy

The Skinny On Body Fat: 4 Surprising Facts

Fat: That bulge when you indulge. And yes, some of us have quite a bit of bulge to show for what we've indulged in. Read

BMI. Body Mass Index. Just hearing those words makes me feel uneasy. This chart, first developed in the mid-19th century, measures our gender, age, height and weight to determine where our health stands.   

You've probably sat and stared at the BMI chart in your doctor’s office and plotted out where you fall. And, if you're like me, you got a knot in your gut when you saw where your fingers met as you scrolled through the rows and columns. Worse yet, your doctor most likely confirmed your fears, advising you to go on a diet to lose weight.

So how accurate is this test? BMI is a good measure in some regards; however, it really doesn’t tell you the whole picture.

Are you one of those people who are strong and physically active yet still falls under the overweight or obese area of the chart? Or, perhaps you're thin, yet feel somewhat weak and fall under the healthy weight category? If this sounds familiar, don’t panic. BMI is not the be all, end all of our health. It's not just our weight and height that measures health; it's the ratio of lean mass to fat mass, something the BMI chart can't determine. 

But, if this chart created and relied upon by physicians doesn’t give us a clear picture, what does?

The answer is simple: you need to get a body composition test. This test will tell you what percentage of your body is comprised of lean mass and what percent is fat mass.   

Wondering why you should take this extra step to assess your health? Let me share with you an example: Take the case of my client, Kim. Kim is in her mid-40s, is 5’7”, weighs 175 pounds and has a classic pear-shaped body. The BMI chart would put Kim at a BMI of 27.4 in the range of overweight. Kim is a woman who has completed numerous marathons, century rides, Olympic and half Ironman triathlons, and trains in CrossFit, yet still worries about her weight. After Kim told me about her athletic endeavors and the struggle she has getting her weight down, I immediately scheduled her for a body composition test. The method we chose was the highly accurate hydrostatic weight method. This test showed Kim’s body fat mass at 19.3% of body weight and her lean mass at 80.7% of body weight. This puts her squarely in the lean range. Far from obese!

Imagine her joy!

Now picture having this knowledge for yourself! I encourage you to get off your scale and THROW IT AWAY. Now that you have done that, schedule a body composition test.

This test can be performed in a few ways. The gold standard is either the hydrostatic weight method or the air displacement method (BodPod). You can do a search near you for either of these tests. If you can't locate one of these tests, you can get a test with skin fold calipers, which is traditionally performed by a personal trainer at a gym, but is not nearly as accurate as the other methods mentioned.

Now that you have your results in hand, if you have excess fat, find a nutrition and fitness program that will not only help you shed excess fat, but increase your lean mass at the same time. Achieving both of these is crucial to good health. I recommend going back every 30 days to retest and see where you stand.

Make sure to visit your physician and have her test your blood pressure, cholesterol, heart rate, etc. If you've succeeded in reducing your body fat, are following a well-balanced diet and are exercising regularly, you'll see an improvement in those numbers.

Finding your body composition will be more helpful (and realistic) than the BMI chart or your scale. Knowing exactly how much fat to lose AND how much muscle to gain is the most effective approach to achieve superb health. Don’t hesitate; do it now!


Photo Credit: Shutterstock.com

You May Also Enjoy

I Didn’t Lose 200 Pounds. I Lost 1 Pound 200 Times

Have you ever looked at a to-do list so staggering you didn't even know where to start? At 440 pounds, that's what it was like to stare down at the scale and know I needed to do something. I  Read

About the Author

Julie Hunter is the founder of Flourish, which provides online wellness coaching that empowers people to live healthy through comprehensive programs that combine nutrition and fitness plans. Additionally, Julie is a certified sports nutritionist, endurance sports coach, life coach, and nationally recognized food expert. She is passionate about helping people find and celebrate their inner superhero.

Comments
Popular